A store selling both light accessories and bulky goods rarely has one sensible delivery charge. A flat rate can overcharge a small order while underpricing a remote delivery. A table-rate extension lets the merchant maintain a predictable tariff using destination and cart information, but the important differences emerge when multiple rules match or a customer changes the basket.
Amasty Shipping Table Rates, Mageplaza Table Rate Shipping and Mirasvit Shipping Table Rates are three Magento extensions for this job. This comparison uses official product pages, documentation and licensing information checked on October 21, 2026. It does not claim live-store testing or measured checkout performance.
Understand the rate engine before choosing a module
A table-rate engine calculates an amount from rules you maintain. It is not automatically a carrier’s live quote service, a warehouse allocation system or a label-purchasing tool. Start with a written tariff: which destinations you serve, what weight means, how dimensions affect the charge and whether mixed baskets use a combined or separate calculation.
Also distinguish creating a new method from changing an existing carrier method or hiding it. These jobs can require different extensions. Buying a table-rate product because it mentions rules will disappoint if the actual requirement is to surcharge a live carrier response. Compare the three products against one explicit shipping model.
| Product | Documented emphasis | Commercial and compatibility checkpoint |
|---|---|---|
| Amasty Shipping Table Rates | Multiple methods, destination/cart conditions, shipping types and delivery information. | Selected price and renewal need confirmation; separate Hyvä Theme and Checkout packages. |
| Mageplaza Table Rate Shipping | Custom methods, volumetric weight, CSV import and estimated delivery information. | Displayed base $179; one-year support selector; verify Commerce cost and API requirements. |
| Mirasvit Shipping Table Rates | Combined conditions, reusable Shipping Areas and priority-based rate selection. | Displayed base $149, then $90 yearly support/updates; Commerce/Cloud surcharges apply. |
Amasty Shipping Table Rates
Amasty supports multiple custom methods with destination, quantity, weight, price and shipping-type conditions. Its guide distinguishes an order-level base charge, per-product amounts, percentages and weight-based charges. That scope is useful when a tariff contains several components rather than one simple destination-to-price lookup. CSV maintenance can be preferable to editing hundreds of rows manually, provided someone owns the source tariff.
Shipping types deserve attention for a mixed catalog. A merchant might need different treatment for fragile goods or oversized items, but the rule configuration must still explain what happens when those products share a basket. Ask the vendor to demonstrate your intended aggregation and exclusions. The strength is configurability; the limitation is the operational work needed to keep overlapping rows understandable.
The product changelog confirms Magento 2.4.9/PHP 8.5 support and earlier 2.4.8/PHP 8.4 compatibility. Confirm the Open Source or Adobe Commerce package for the exact patch in use. The manual identifies amasty/module-shipping-table-rates-hyva and amasty/module-shipping-table-rates-hyva-checkout; access is tied to an active product or support subscription. They address different storefront surfaces.
Selected first-year and renewal prices were not reliably exposed in the accessible product text. Obtain a quote that includes edition, support period and any subscription-only delivery-information features. Amasty licenses one copy per Magento installation. Multiple store-view assignments are configuration scope, not permission to deploy the same license across independent stores.
Mageplaza Table Rate Shipping
Mageplaza highlights destination, weight, order value and quantity rules, alongside volumetric weight and CSV import. This makes it a sensible candidate when delivery pricing depends on the space a parcel occupies as well as its actual mass. The useful evaluation is a bulky lightweight item against a compact heavy item, using your carrier’s dimensional divisor and rounding rules.
The live page retrieved for this review identifies version 4.1.3; older indexed release text can still show 4.1.2. Its release notes include Magento 2.4.9 and PHP 8.5 compatibility, while the displayed platform range is 2.4.4–2.4.9. Community and Enterprise/Magento Cloud are separate selections. Confirm your exact patch, PHP branch and selected edition before purchase.
Both Hyvä Theme and Hyvä Checkout are advertised. However, the page invites merchants to ask about API/GraphQL requirements. A headless or PWA store should therefore obtain a concrete supported integration plan rather than assume that server-side rate calculation means every frontend is already supported. Include address changes and payment-provider express buttons in that demonstration.
The displayed base is $179 with one year of support selected. Installation messaging includes a free offer and a separate service amount, so verify the actual basket rather than relying on a promotion banner. Exact renewal and Commerce totals were not confirmed. Mageplaza’s license permits one live Magento installation with unlimited test installations; confirm additional websites and store views in your proposed setup. The practical advantage is tariff-oriented functionality, with procurement detail still requiring a selected quote.
Mirasvit Shipping Table Rates
Mirasvit creates separate shipping methods, each with its own rate table. Its documentation describes combined weight, subtotal, quantity and destination conditions, plus fixed, per-product, percentage and per-weight charges. Minimum and maximum charges can bound the result. The distinction is useful when the merchant needs a deterministic matrix rather than a loose collection of cart-price adjustments.
Shipping Areas add reusable conditions involving products, stock, time or customer information. A rate can reference an area rather than repeat the same logic throughout the tariff. That offers a way to organize complex coverage, but it also introduces a dependency: the person changing an area must understand which rates use it. Treat deletion and renaming as configuration changes that need review.
Rate priority is explicit: higher-priority matches win, with the cheapest chosen among equal-priority matches, and a stop-processing option is available. Ask to see an overlap case, not only a basket that matches one row. That clarity is a strength when debugging a quote; it still requires your tariff to express the right precedence.
The vendor lists Open Source and Adobe Commerce 2.3–2.4.9 and displays $149 for the base selection, one year of support/updates, then $90 per year. Commerce and Cloud carry additional edition costs. The license is per Magento installation. A precise PHP matrix and a product-specific Hyvä/Luma/PWA support matrix were not established from the reviewed page; obtain written confirmation for your checkout rather than inferring support from another Mirasvit extension.
Build a tariff acceptance sheet
Use concrete expected quotes. Include a local lightweight basket, a heavy regional basket, a remote postcode, a missing postcode, a mixed bulky-and-small order and a basket above a free-shipping threshold. Repeat with a coupon and with tax included and excluded. Specify whether the threshold uses the original subtotal or the discounted amount.
Check boundary values: exactly the weight limit, just above it, zero weight, decimal quantities if relevant, and the edges of a postcode range. Imported spreadsheets can change decimal separators, leading zeros and character encoding. A successful import message alone does not prove that an alphanumeric postcode or a weight band means what the merchant intended.
Then examine the full checkout path. A guest changes country, logs in, changes quantity and selects a different payment method. The shipping amount should be recalculated consistently in the cart, checkout, order and administrative view. If your business uses multi-source inventory, decide whether the tariff depends on stock origin and obtain a demonstration of that exact interaction.
Budget and choose for maintainability
All three are paid extensions; a free installation offer or demo does not create a free functional edition. Add license renewals, compatibility work, tariff maintenance and any separate carrier or restriction services to the purchase cost. Record the Magento edition, exact version, PHP version, theme, checkout and production-installation count in the quote.
Choose Amasty when its shipping types and delivery presentation fit a tariff your team can maintain. Shortlist Mageplaza when volumetric pricing is central and its documented storefront support fits your checkout. Favor Mirasvit when reusable areas and explicit rate precedence match the way you organize coverage. In every case, the most useful winner is the product that produces your acceptance-sheet amounts with explainable rules.
Review our Magento checkout comparison before combining a new rate engine with a checkout replacement. Shipping configuration and checkout compatibility should be evaluated together.
Official sources
Checked October 21, 2026: Amasty product/changelog, Amasty manual, Amasty license, Mageplaza product/release notes, Mageplaza license, Mirasvit product/pricing, and Mirasvit license.